|
Medical
Insurance—No Money, No Medicine!
Unlike many foreign countries like Canada, the
United States does not offer a national health
care system. Residents of the United States are
not entitled to health care. Rather, they
must secure their own health care plans in order
to receive the best health care possible. Over
the years, it has become very expensive to obtain
health care in the United States. The government
provides minimal assistance to citizens unless
they are elderly or poor. People who immigrate
to the USA late in life face special problems
(See Medicare and Medicaid for more information
on health care for seniors and low income families).
The USA has some of the best medical facilities,
trained doctors and equipment, but you had better
be rich, poor or have medical insurance if you
want to be able to take advantage of these services.
Managed
Care—Your Answer to the Health Care Riddle
In the past, health care
was provided by independent doctors and hospitals.
Managed care refers to a health care system
that links doctors, hospitals and insurance plans.
Under managed care, the patient becomes part of
an organized provider system. This organized
system is an arrangement between doctors, hospitals
and pharmacies to provide health care at a reduced
cost to patients.
There
are several different health care plans in use
today. Each is briefly discussed below, with
links for more information. The two most important
plans are:
HMO (Health Maintenance Organizations);
and
PPO (Preferred Provider Organizations).
HMO—Health
Maintenance Organizations
HMOs
are an excellent choice for those patients who
wish to save money on health care costs while
still receiving quality care. The HMO is a very
tight network of doctors, hospitals and health
care providers who have a contract with medical
insurance companies. This contract allows the
medical insurance company to receive discounted
health care services, which they pass onto their
members. Some HMO companies actually own
their hospitals and directly employ doctors,
nurses and physiotherapists. By doing this, the
HMO can control the cost of health care while
still providing some of the best facilities and
services in the world. In essence, an HMO is a
web of doctors, hospitals and pharmacies, all
connected to one another by the HMO. In order
to receive discounted rates through the HMO, a
patient can only be treated by doctors who are
part of the “web.”
When
patients enroll in an HMO, they are required to
select a “family doctor,” also known as a Primary
Care Physician (PCP) or Health Care Provider (HCP).
The family doctor provides all of the basic care
for these patients, including annual exams, vaccinations,
routine health problems, etc. Typically, when
patients visit their family doctor (PCP or HCP),
they are required to pay a small fee known as
a “co-pay.” A co-pay is the portion of the doctor’s
bill that you are responsible for paying. This
co-pay is paid directly to the family doctor,
and is around $5 to $40. The co-pay amount will
vary depending on the type of medical plan you
have. The family doctor then bills the HMO for
the remainder of his or her reduced fee. Patients
are not required to submit any claims or additional
payments.
EXAMPLE—John and The HMO
The
best way to understand an HMO is to look at
a specific scenario.
John
is a member of an HMO. He has selected a family
doctor (PCP or HCP) named Dr. Brown. Dr. Brown
will act as the foundation for all of John’s
healthcare. He will provide annual exams to
John as well as treat John for any routine illnesses.
John visits Dr. Brown for regular checkups and
pays his co-pay for each visit. During one
of his routine exams, Dr. Brown hears an irregularity
in John’s heartbeat. To further determine the
cause of the irregularity, Dr. Brown decides
to refer John to a heart specialist for testing.
He refers John to Dr. Thomas, who is a heart
specialist. Since Dr. Thomas is also a doctor
contracted by the HMO, John only has to pay
his normal co-pay. The HMO is notified of the
referral and reimburses Dr. Thomas accordingly.
If
John did not have any health insurance, he would
have to pay for his visit to Dr. Brown and Dr.
Thomas. The bill would most likely have totaled
several hundred, if not thousands of dollars.
If this had been the case, John may not have
gotten the care he needed because he would have
been unable to pay for the costs associated
with the necessary treatments. John’s case
is certainly a small one in comparison to a
patient requiring major surgery or long term
care. A patient being treated for cancer undergoes
extensive testing and drug therapy, and the
total cost can reach hundreds of thousands of
dollars. This is simply too much for a single
person to afford without health insurance.
Under an HMO, that same cancer patient could
receive the care he or she needed with minimal
out-of-pocket expense.
HMO Advantages
and Disadvantages—No Plan is Perfect for Everyone!
Benefits
of an HMO
ü
Minimal expense to patient.
Because patients select one doctor for all primary
healthcare, the costs are substantially lower
and the patient is only required to pay a small
co-pay for services.
ü
Ease of use: Because doctors
in an HMO are part of a network, all billing goes
directly through the HMO. In most cases, the
patient is only required to pay the co-pay at
the time of service.
ü
Preventive healthcare. HMOs
want their members to stay healthy. It is more
cost effective to keep patients healthy by offering
routine care than to allow them to get sick.
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.”
Disadvantages
of an HMO
While
HMOs may seem ideal, there are some drawbacks
to consider.
Patients
MUST choose a PCP. While there are many excellent
doctors contracted by HMOs, your favorite family
physician may not be one of them. If he or she
is not contracted by the HMO, you cannot see him/her
and receive coverage.
Because
HMOs are “managed health care” systems, the ultimate
decisions regarding what services are covered
and what services are not covered lies with the
HMO itself. The purpose of this management is
to prevent doctors from ordering needless (and
costly) tests and treatments. The HMO determines
what is reasonable and necessary. While in most
cases, this does not interfere with a patient’s
medical care, there have been cases where HMOs
have denied payment on treatments they consider
ineffective or “experimental.”
For
more information on HMOs, including specific plan
options, check out these websites:
www.insweb.com This is a comprehensive insurance website. You
can request instant quotes for various types of
insurance policies, including medical insurance.
The site also provides basic information on medical
insurance terminology.
http://www.usnews.com/usnews/nycu/health/hehmoqz.htm
This link offers a self-evaluation test which
you can take to determine whether or not an HMO
is right for you.
http://www.ncqa.org This site rates managed
care plans using a “report card” system. You
can view many different HMO Plans available today,
and see how they rank in various categories (accessibility,
qualified providers, etc)
PPO--Preferred
Provider Organization
An
alternative to the HMO is the PPO. Like an HMO,
a PPO contracts doctors for a reduced fee. However,
a PPO is more flexible in its requirements of
patients. While there is still a “web” of healthcare
providers, the web is not as tight as the HMO
and because of this, patients can choose to seek
care outside the web. However, the flexibility
to choose doctors in or out of the web comes at
a price. Patients often have more out-of-pocket
expense when they use out of network doctors.
While this type of plan may be inappropriate for
some people, others prefer the flexibility to
choose doctors based on their own preferences.
Like
an HMO, PPOs typically require patients to select
a family doctor, often referred to as a primary
care physician (PCP) or Health Care Provider (HCP).
A PPO contracts healthcare providers just like
an HMO. If patients decide to seek care from
the providers within the web, they will save money,
oftentimes only needing to pay a small co-pay
(usually between $5-$40, however this varies depending
on the plan). However, patients also have the
option of seeking care outside the web. Consequently,
patients can consult a specialist or second physician
whenever they feel it necessary. However, they
are strongly encouraged to see physicians who
are part of the network. If they don't, they are
reimbursed less -- anywhere from 80 to 100 percent
reimbursement for treatment by PPO providers versus
60 to 70 percent for treatment by physicians outside
the network. Additional features of the PPO include
deductibles. A deductible is the amount you are
required to pay before the medical insurance company
will kick in payments. Depending on the plan,
the deductible can be anywhere from $250 to $5,000.
Once you’ve met your annual deductible, the insurance
company can begin paying benefits. Additionally,
some plans have a co-insurance maximum. This
maximum is the amount you pay before the insurance
company will cover your care 100%.
For
example, if a patient has a plan that offers 80%/60%
coverage, with a $500 deductible and a $5,000
co-insurance maximum, the patient would:
1)
pay the first $500 of medical care received, then
2)
pay either 20% or 40% of the next $5,000 in medical
care bills (percentage depends on whether the
doctor is in the network or out of the network).
After
the $5,000 maximum has been reached, the insurance
company will pay 100% of medical care bills.
EXAMPLE—John
and The PPO
The
best way to understand a PPO is to look at a
specific scenario.
John
is a member of a PPO. John chose a family doctor
(PCP or HCP) for routine care. He did this
to save money—PPO’s offer greater coverage when
the patient visits doctors that are within the
primary network. John’s routine care only costs
him a small percentage of the total bill because
he is using an in-network doctor and has met
his annual deductible of $250. During one of
his visits, his doctor notices the irregular
heartbeat and decides to refer John to a specialist.
The doctor tells John that he’d like to refer
him to Dr. Thomas, a specialist within the PPO
network. John decides he would rather see Dr.
Michaels. Since Dr. Michaels is not part of
the PPO network, John is required to pay a higher
percentage of his bill. The PPO will still
cover part of the cost (usually 60 to 70 percent),
but will not cover it all. By doing this, the
PPO encourages patients to use doctors within
the network. However, the PPO is flexible enough
to allow a patient to seek care out of the network
if he or she is willing to pay some of the cost.
PPO
Advantages and Disadvantages—No Plan is Perfect
for Everyone!
Benefits
of a PPO
ü Flexibility.
Patients can visit doctors within the web (network),
and receive coverage from 80 to 100 percent, or
go out-of-network and receive coverage ranging
from 60 to 70 percent of the total medical bill.
ü The
care that a patient receives is not dictated by
an HMO. If a patient wants to see an acupuncturist
(not covered by most HMOs) for care, he or she
may do that, and possibly be partially covered
by the PPO.
ü If
patients are not happy with a particular doctor,
or wants a second, third, fourth, etc. opinion,
they are allowed to visit any doctor. The coverage
amount is not as high as in-network doctor visits,
but the coverage offered does offset some of the
costs.
ü PPOs typically
cost less than HMOs because the patient is required
to pay a higher portion of the bill.
Disadvantages
of a PPO
Cost.
For patients looking to spend as little as possible,
a PPO can be somewhat expensive. Since the patient
is often paying a percentage of the care, it can
cost significantly more than an HMO co-pay. Additionally,
patients may be required to pay a deductible before
benefits kick in.
Oftentimes,
the patient is required to file a claim with the
insurance company. While an HMO automatically
bills the participating doctor, a PPO may require
the patient to file a claim for an out-of-network
doctor visit. This can be time consuming and
oftentimes confusing.
Note:
The above is a general explanation of HMO’s and
PPO’s. There are many types of programs and they
do vary.
|